Minimalist Wars are Made to Lose!
I am furious that Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice promised Lebanon 30 million dollars to help rebuild that county’s infrastructure!
Why?
Look, if Lebanon had the testicular fortitude of 4-year-old boy, they would have been out there, in boondocks, at least TRYING to root out Hizbollah. But, no, they don’t do that. They sit on their hands; allow themselves to be intimidated by a bunch of armed hoodlums, and wait for Israel to save their sorry asses! Then they turn right around and “hate” Israel and the US… as always!
Oh, come on, folks! The Moslems, we have learned, are afraid of their own shadows. They will attack from ambush, or set off bombs in locations with high concentrations of civilians, and even stoop to killing their own civilians, and swear, to the press, that either the Israelis did it, or the Americans did it! Does that sound like brave people to you? If it does, you have a warped sense of bravery, and NO sense of honor, at all.
You know, the more familiar I become with that area of the world, and the peoples of that area of the world, the more I become convinced that Saddam Hussein was on to something. Granted he was a dictator. But he kept those people under control. He used raw fear.
The US is attempting to us tender loving care… and it ain’t working!
Reminds me of the old tale of the farmer who was searching for a new mule to plow with. He inquired at another farm, where he had seen a sign declaring the farmer there had a mule for sale. As the prospective buyer looked the mule over, he asked how the mule responded to orders. The owner of the mule said the mule responded well, but you had to use tender loving care to get the mule to respond at peak performance. If you did that the mule was up to any task. Asked by the buyer to demonstrate, the owner hitched the mule to a plowshare and snapped the reins over the mules back and commanded “gid-UP”. The mule didn’t move. Didn’t even flinch. Three times the owner repeated the command and the mule didn’t move. Finally the owner stepped over to a pile of cast off wood scraps, picked up a four foot section of 2 x 4 and, swinging it with all his might, smacked the mule right between the eyes! The astounded buyer shouted: “I thought you said the mule would respond to tender loving care!” The owner replied: “He will. But you got to get his attention first!”
The kernel of truth in that old story can be applied to the Middle Eastern Moslems. We haven’t gotten their attention yet! As long as we use the tender loving care, BEFORE the 2 x 4, we will NEVER get their attention.
Frankly, I’m not convinced that democracy will work in that part of the world. It doesn’t carry the implied threat that a strongman dictator does. Plus, I am not convinced that all people want to be free. You see free people have responsibility for themselves. Many people, on this planet, do not want to be responsible for themselves. We learned that the hard way right here in this country. We have an entire class of people who appear content to remain wards of the US government. Have we learned nothing from this? Apparently not!
The US may find that we are forced to install another strongman dictator, in power in Iraq, and forget about democracy until the Iraqis grow up.
Meanwhile, back in Lebanon, Israel’s attempt at a minimalist war is failing. If Hizbollah is given even the smallest reason to claim a victory, it will bring more death and destruction down on Israel.
When Gen. Douglas Macarthur led the US troops in Korea against the North Koreans and the Red Chinese, he had the idea that once he had driven them back across the 38th parallel he would sow the land, five miles deep, with radio active cobalt, to insure there would not be another land invasion from North Korea into South Korea. President Truman thought Mac was crazy and eventually fired him. The fact that Mac was planning to run against Truman as the Republican candidate for President in the next election had absolutely nothing to do with Truman’s decision to relieve the good general! Nothing!
Now, think about it. If Israel unloaded a few battlefield “tactical” nukes, into the area of southern Lebanon, the Hizbollah terrorist are using to launch their stove pipe missiles from, seems to me that would create a “sanitary zone”. Anything moving about in that zone would die of radiation sickness in fairly short order. It might prove a deterrent to terrorists and end the fighting in that area for many, many, years to come.
The point is… the fighting in Southern Lebanon, now, is useless. Even if Israel drives the Hizbollah back, oh, say, 20 miles, Hizbollah will simply request, and receive, longer-range missiles from Iran and/or Syria. So nothing is to be gained by simply driving the Hizbollah back. However, killing as many Hizbollah terrorists, as is possible, will certainly be looked upon, with favor, by Israelis and Americans alike.
Unfortunately, the US, and now Israel, it seems, have both bought into the lie that minimalist wars win hearts and minds. They don’t. What a minimalist war does do, however, is cause wars to drag on, and on, and in the process, cause more soldiers to die needlessly. A lightening fast, sharp as a razor, military strike followed by another, and another, until none of the enemy is left standing is the proven way to gain victory in any conflict. Lightening War, invented by the Nazis, proved it’s worth, as a war-fighting tactic, as far back as September 1st, 1939 when Hitler’s army flooded across Poland’s border and wrapped that entire country up in a matter of days.
And finally, minimalist wars are interpreted, by a hostile media, as “quagmires”.
It is apparent, and has been since the Vietnam War, the mainstream media, worldwide, is hostile to America and to Israel. Even in the US, itself, it’s own homegrown media is hostile to the US. As a result they look for any, and all, reasons to portray the US and Israel in a bad light. They jump on a minimalist war and interpret it to their readers, and viewers, as a loss for the US and for Israel. That is exactly what is happening on the front pages of the newspapers across the world, and on the TV screens around the world, today.
When America or Israel goes to war, it must gear up to fight both enemies; the ones shooting at them and the ones writing about them.
If I could offer any advice, at all, to the US government, and the Israeli government, it would be two things: Do not fight minimalist wars! Strike with overwhelming force… and do it from day one. And secondly… bar the press from the theatre of war…period! No press, no press conferences… no nothing… until the fighting is ended.
Longstreet
10 comments:
I agree, it really ticks me off that our Government is si free with our money. They are constantly giving to people who do not deserve it and will still hate us.
It's very broad of you to categorize the "Moslems" as the one's bombing "you"...
Generalizations... tisk tisk - they are radicals with their own agendas. Agendas that are not set forth by the "Muslim" community as a whole.
They represent a section of the World/Middle East population.
The way you generalize - if we applied the same broad thinking to, lets say - your postal system, then all US Postal employees are crazed lunatics that shoot their co-workers.
They're bombing "You" because "You" are somewhere you don't belong trying to fix things that you obviously don't understand with methods that obviously don't work.
"You" being the U.S. (I'm generalizing of course...)
Violence begets violence... Ever heard of poking an angry dog with a sharp stick... The U.S. Is so easy to provoke...
A wise man (a Muslim actually) once said:
"To make war is easy - to make peace, that takes patience, time and hard work."
There is no such thing as a Proportionate Response either. I hammer that down on my blog.
If death is the only bargaining chip then make sure it is their death you are making a bargain for.
Seaspook - You are right as well in our governments horrific acts with our money. Look at our national debt and tell me we don't already have a place that that money needs to go.
"Anonymous said...
It's very broad of you to categorize the "Moslems" as the one's bombing "you"..."
***************
Anonymous, that smokescreen doesn't work anymore... if it ever did. The fact is... nobody is bombing us BUT MOSLEMS!!!
You might want to read my piece of July 19th. We now know this is a war about religion. We KNOW that! The US government is trying to be politically correct, and not say it out loud, altho it is the elephant in the room!
Isreal should be rebuilding Lebannon. The Lebanize government just came out of a civil war 10 years ago and is not that stable as it is. This is just what Hezzbola needs to get stronger, Isreal to go in and start this unjust punishment of civilians. I have a plan for peace, give Palestine back, give each Isrealy a bag of seed and 10 heads of swine and ship them off to Antartica, where ther is no one for these "people" to war with. Don't worry God will take care of "his people".
Frank, you can't give something back... that never was in the first place. Palestine NEVER existed! It was simply the name the Romans applied to what we now call the "Holy Land" while they occupied it. Even the Arab nations will not take the so-called Palestinians. On top of that the state called "Trans-Jordan" was given to the so-called Palestinians, as a "homeland", at roughly the same time as Israel was given to the Israelis. The Palestinians didn't want it. They wanted Israel... to be more correct, they wanted Israel GONE!
The so-called Palestinians are the outcasts of the Arab nations. They are trouble makers no matter where they go. Jordan threw them out, as well.
I don't get two things:
Why the Left hates Jews so... and secondly, why American Jews, by a vast majority, vote Democrat. I cannot fathom that at all.
The left doesn't hate Jews, we just see there agression for what it is. We also see there lies, 60% of the Jews alive in 1933 didn't live in Germany, there is census info to back it up. No way Hitler killed that many, number 1. Jews in this country, the majority of them are not Zionists and don't buy into their "One world or no world crap." for 2. Here is writings and a speach from a Jewish defector, he outlines the Zionist agenda, it actually sounds Left, but I believe over time the revesed course, because the right capitulates to Isreal every chance it gets. Why do you believe that a nation who lied about it's own brethern (War for Southern Independence) would not still lie today? Are you naive, the Republicans fooled you once, betrayed you and your forefathers even in the eyes of history, to remove a "scar from the face of this nation" and you now "kiss butt" to these guys every chance you get. Well here's the link, I sent it before.
http://users.cyberone.com.au/myers/freedman.html
I’m sorry, Frank. I STILL don’t get it!
We Southerners are close to our Jewish brethren. Always have been. Over 10,000 Jewish soldiers fought for the Confederacy. When hostilities broke out, in 1861, the largest Jewish population in this country was located in Charleston, SC.
Here’s some more from: http://cgi.stanford.edu/group/wais/cgi-bin/index.php?p=387
“Before the 1890’s, most American Jews lived in the South, and they were highly assimilated and very prominent in Southern politics and society. Jews are particularly prominent in the history of Charleston, South Carolina, the site of the first synagogue ever built in the Western Hemisphere, and the original charter of South Carolina, written by the great philosopher John Locke himself in 1669, guaranteed religious freedom for Jews and encouraged their immigration to South Carolina. Many of the Charleston militia sent to fight the British in the American War of Independence were Jews (Lushington’s famous company was more than half Jewish), and history records that the very first monetary contribution to the Southern cause in the Civil War came from Charleston’s prominent merchant Benjamin Mordecai.
During the Civil War, just to name a few prominent Jews in the South, the Speaker of the Louisiana House (Edwin Moise) and Louisiana’s Lieutenant Governer (H.M. Hyams) were Jews, and during the Civil War, the Mayor of Richmond, capital of the Confederacy, was a Jew (later connected by family ties to Confederate president Jefferson Davis), and of course Judah Benjamin was variously the Secretary of State and Secretary of War of the Confederate government.
Judah Benjamin was a fascinating, incredibly talented character, who had three or four separate careers and reached the very top of his profession in every one. He was described at various times as the “Confederacy’s Brilliant Statesman” and the “Dark Prince of the Confederacy”. He was opposed to slavery (like Robert E. Lee, he had freed his own slaves long before the war), but as a real Southern patriot and exquisite orator he was the leading voice in the U.S. Senate for Southern interests in the build-up to the war. His debates with Daniel Webster on the U.S. Senate floor are thought by many to be the greatest ever held in that venue. Benjamin was appointed to the U.S. Supreme Court by Millard Fillmore but turned down the post in order to continue defending the South in the Senate. After the war, he was so embittered by the Confederate defeat that he fled the country in disguise via Cuba and thence to England, where penniless, he started all over again at the age of 55 as a law student in the Inns of Court. He reached the top of his profession yet again, being acknowledged eventually as England’s foremost jurist. His treatise on the English law of sales is the all-time classic on the subject and is still in print to this day. He was the only lawyer ever to be given a dinner in parliament in honor of his retirement.”
Frank, let me point out, also, the Jews Hitler killed didn’t just come from Germany. No... he collected them from all over Europe (The area he conquered.) Even American Jews, in Europe to visit, or to study, were hauled away and killed by
Hitler.
You should know that all Israelites were not Jews. Only those from the tribe of Judah were, in fact, Jews. It is much the same in modern Israel today. Only a portion of the Israelis are Jews. For a time, there were more Jews in New York City than there were in Israel! Heck, it may still be that way, I haven’t checked.
You may recall that Golda Meir, the former prime Minister of Israel, was from Cleveland Ohio!
I STILL can’t fathom the hatred of the Jewish people. It makes absolutely no sense to me. None!
judeah is made up of 12 tribes (the 12 tribes of Isreal). But I worked with a Jewish guy from Russia (actually a couple of them) when I asked him what tribe he was from he said that that has nothing to do with it anymore. FYI, ole' friend.
BIBLICAL ISRAEL was made up of 12 tribes. The tribe of JUDAH, from which the Jews derive their name, was only ONE of those tribes.
There were a couple of "half- tribes", too, if memory serves.
Post a Comment