Predicting America's Future
By Alan
Caruba
One of the
great parlor games of pundits, politicians, journalists, and just about
everyone else is predicting the future.
There’s a
wonderful book, “The Experts Speak”, that is filled, page after page, with predictions
and pronouncements by people of presumed wisdom and knowledge, all of which
turned out to be often hilariously wrong. In 1913, regarding Einstein’s theory
of relativity, Ernst Mach, a professor of physics at the University of Vienna,
said, “I can accept the theory of relativity as little as I can accept the
existence of atoms and other such dogmas.”
I prefer
optimists to pessimists and the co-authors of “America 3.0: Rebooting American
Prosperity in the 21st Century—why America’s Greatest Days Are Yet
to Come”, James C. Bennett and Michael J. Lotus, are optimists.
In his
foreword to the book, Glenn Harlan Reynolds, better known as the “Instapundit”,
cites the late economist, Herbert Stein, who said “Something that can’t go on forever,
won’t”, noting that “The American 2.0 approach, which delivered stability and
prosperity to many for decades, is now more problem than solution, as banks
fail, bureaucrats flounder, and the economy fails to deliver the jobs—or the
tax revenues—needed to keep the whole enterprise going.” Reynolds, however,
agrees that “The Jeffersonian individualism that was embodied in in America 1.0
never really went away.” And that’s the good news.
Bennett
and Lotus begin by saying, “We are optimistic about the long-term prospects for
American freedom and prosperity. You should be, too.” They do not believe the
nation is “on an inevitable road to tyranny and poverty. Predictions of the end
of America are deeply mistaken,” but they do say that “The current politico-economic
regime is falling apart.”
I think
most people will agree with that as a deeply divided America struggles to deal
with slow economic growth, a Marxist President, and the final gasp of a
government that has expanded to a point of demonstrating the wisdom of the
Constitution’s limits on its size and role. The Tea Party movement and the
founding principles of the Republican Party are all about those limitations.
As
Obamacare fails dramatically, Americans across the political spectrum will want
to return to a more manageable, less intrusive government. They did that when
they elected Ronald Reagan. America
needs a leader to emerge who will bring the two factions together and, if
history is a guide, they will find one. It will not be easy because two
generations have passed through the liberal indoctrination of its schools and
because the nation’s media, composed of those graduates, is dominated by
liberals.
Another
factor is demography, the study of populations. Americans are living longer and
the effects of that are undermining the future of progressive programs such as
Social Security and Medicare. At some point they will have to be reformed,
along with the rising costs of medical care.
Americans,
since the early years of the last century have gone back and forth between
progressive programs and a yearning for less control from centralized
government. The income tax, the government’s “safety net” introduced following
the Great Depression, the growth and decline of unions, and even Prohibition demonstrate
this ambivalence. Obamacare is likely to be repealed just as Prohibition was.
America
1.0 stretched from the century the preceded the Revolution and extended to the
Civil War. It was a largely agrarian society of farmers with the emphasis on
individual responsibility. It was, as well, a society based on the nuclear
family, a structure that remains today, though is under attack by liberals.
America 2.0 saw the rise of industrialization and, following World War Two, the
nation as a superpower in the world.
America
2.0 is crumbling, say the authors, and that “we are in the midst of slow but
wrenching transition to an emerging America 3.0.” It will be “an even bigger
transition, from industrial to an individualized-and-networked economy that we
are undergoing now.”
One of the
elements of the transition that the authors recommend is the abolishment of the
federal income tax and replacing it with a national consumption tax, saying
that “The required disclosure of personal economic information required in
filing tax forms constitutes perhaps the largest single invasion of civil
liberties in America, violating the spirit of the Fourth Amendment’s guarantee
against search and seizure of personal information without a judicial warrant.”
Here
again, putting the Internal Revenue in change of enforcing Obamacare will
likely trigger a backlash against it, the income tax system, and generate a
return to the individual rights enumerated in the Constitution.
Then, too,
the world is also changing as Islamism seeks to drag its population back to a
dark age of feudalism and slavery. The wave of terrorism is generating a
backlash, even in nations where Islam is the dominant faith. America, in the
process, has learned it cannot export its unique democratic system and engage
in “nation building.” The original faith in the United Nations to deter wars
has faded and the growth of various regional organizations will likely replace
it.
The
co-authors of “America 3.0” say “We can sketch only the bare outlines of what
an America 3.0 defense and foreign policy might be like in reality. But those
policies must be consistent with what can actually be achieved by American
power, with a renewed focus on securing the global commons for trade,
maintaining our alliances, and defending the American free and prosperous way
of life.”
We are
living in times of both rapid and slow change, and America has the
mechanism—the Constitution—to make the changes needed to adjust and the strength
to protect itself from enemies, domestic and foreign, in a global economy. It
won’t be easy and it will not be fast enough for most, but America will remain
a dominant agent for change.
© Alan
Caruba, 2013
******************************
Alan Caruba's commentaries are posted daily at "Warning Signs" and shared on dozens
of news and opinion websites. His blog recently passed more than 3 million page
views. If
you love to read, visit his monthly report on new books at Bookviews. For information on his professional
skills, Caruba Editorial Services is the place to go!
You can find Alan Caruba on both Facebook and Twitter as well.
No comments:
Post a Comment